Home Improvement, Remodeling and Repair @ Builders Websource. Home design software, advice, tools, videos, tech notes, links and more!

Search: 

Home Page | Books | BuildersTALK | Building a Dream | Green Building | Links | Software | Tech Notes | Tools | Contact

Messages and Online Forum Q&A

If you find the answer to this question useful, kindly CLICK TO PAY here.



Knowledge


BuildersTALK
Building|Dream
Green Building
How-To Books
Links (Web)
Newsletter
Tech Notes
Videos

Software


BeamChek
Bidding
CAD | AutoCAD
Estimating
EZHomeBuild
Home Design
Landscaping
Lighting Design
PrioSoft
Resi-Cost
Structural

Specialty Tools


CrackMON
Tools
WatrLevel

Support & Info


About Us
Advertise
Contact Us
FAQ
Publish
Services
Support

 

Re: HVAC - Heat Pump vs. Traditional Heating/Cooling

From: info@builderswebsource.com
Category: HVAC
Remote Name: 63.198.181.43
Date: 03 Nov 2002
Time: 01:40 AM

Comments

The efficiency and operating costs of heat pumps vs. traditional high efficiency furnaces and air conditioning systems requires an in-depth analysis of your particular conditions. The location and type of construction, as well as the relative costs of natural gas vs. electricity all factor into the equation. Generally, your local utility company can provide guidance, or help you conduct an audit, to make an educated choice. Often, heat pumps can save 30-40% over traditional electrical heating. However, gas heating is often much less expensive, making the comparison more difficult. An unbiased source of factual information on heat pumps is available from the US Department of Energy at http://www.eren.doe.gov/buildings/consumer_information/heatpump/ where you'll find a range of FAQs on heat pumps. For our readers' convenience, some of this information is excerpted here:

Heat Pump FAQs. Source: US Department of Energy

Why Buy An Energy Efficient Heat Pump?

If you use electricity to heat your home, consider installing an energy-efficient heat pump system. Heat pumps are the most efficient form of electric heating in mild and moderate climates, providing two to three times more heating than the equivalent amount of energy they consume in electricity. Air source heat pumps are recommended for mild and moderate climate regions, where the winter temperatures usually remain above 30°F. Ground source (also known as geothermal) heat pumps are more efficient and economical to operate when compared to conventional air source heat pumps, especially in climates with similar heating and cooling loads.

About Heat Pump Efficiency

Three types of heat pumps are typically available for residences: (1) air-to-air, (2) water source, and (3) ground source. Heat pumps collect heat from the air, water, or ground outside your home and concentrate it for use inside. Heat pumps operate in reverse to cool your home by collecting the heat inside your house and effectively pumping it outside. Heat pumps have both heating and cooling ratings-both in terms of capacity and efficiency. Capacity ratings are generally in British thermal unit (Btu) per hour or tons (one ton equals 12,000 Btu/hr). Heating efficiency for air source heat pumps is indicated by the heating season performance factor (HSPF). The HSPF tells you the ratio of the seasonal heating output in Btu's divided by the seasonal power consumption in Watt-hours. A heat pump can supply 2 to 3 times as much heat as it consumes in electricity because it moves energy from outside to inside (or vice versa). Heat pump efficiency varies with outdoor temperature. The performance of an air source heat pump in heating mode decreases with the drop in outside air temperature. The actual seasonal efficiency (as opposed to the rating) is therefore higher in a mild climate than in a severe cold climate. In the cooling mode, a heat pump operates exactly like a central air conditioner. The seasonal energy efficiency ratio (SEER) is analogous to the HSPF but tells you the seasonal cooling performance. Federal efficiency standards require that conventional heat pumps have an HSPF rating of at least 6.8 and a SEER rating of at least 10.0. The most efficient air source heat pumps have an HSPF rating between 9.0 and 10.0 and a SEER above 14 or so.

Tips for Buying a New Heat Pump

Heat pumps must be sized and installed properly to work efficiently. Heat pumps are sized for either the heating demand or cooling demand, depending on which implies the larger unit (almost always cooling). However, heat pumps do not perform well over extended periods of sub-freezing temperature and it may not be cost effective to meet all your heating needs with an air-source heat pump. Ground source heat pumps (GSHPs) are more efficient and less noisy than conventional air-source heat pumps. Though GSHPs are more expensive to install, the dramatic improvement in efficiency can yield attractive life cycle cost savings. However, the appropriateness of a GSHP depends on the size of your lot, the conditions of the subsoil and landscape, and sometimes the relative magnitudes of summer cooling and winter heating requirements. Select a heat pump with a higher HSPF. For units with comparable HSPF ratings, check their steady-state rating at -8.3°C, the low temperature setting. The unit with the higher rating will be more efficient. Select a heat pump with a demand-defrost control. This will minimize the defrost cycles thereby reducing supplementary and heat pump energy use. Select a heat pump with an outdoor sound rating of 7.6 bels or lower. The lower the value, the less noisy the outdoor unit. If installing a heat pump in an existing home without an existing heat pump or air conditioner, ductwork may need to be enlarged. Heat pump systems generally require larger duct sizes than other central heating systems. For proper heat pump operation, air flow should be 50 to 60 liters per second per kilowatt-hour or 400 to 500 cubic foot per minute per ton of cooling capacity. If a heat pump is added to an electric furnace, the heat pump coil can usually be placed on the cold (upstream) side of the furnace for greatest efficiency. Fans and compressors make noise. Locate the outdoor unit away from windows and adjacent buildings. Some units also make noise when they vibrate. You can reduce this noise by selecting quiet equipment or by mounting the unit on a noise-absorbing base.

Tips for Lowering Your Heat Pump's Energy Usage

Do not manually set back a heat pump's thermostat at night. Without a thermostat specifically designed for heat pump set-back, the electric resistance backup heat will engage when the thermostat is raised in the morning, resulting in much higher energy consumption. Continuous indoor fan operation can degrade heat pump performance unless a high-efficiency, variable-speed fan motor is used. Operate the system on the "auto" fan setting on the thermostat. Clean or change filters once a month or as needed, and maintain the system according to manufacturer's instructions. Filter and coil maintenance have a dramatic impact on system performance and service life. Dirty filters, coils, and fans reduce airflow through the system. Reduced airflow decreases system performance and can lead to compressor damage if it continues for an extended period. Clean and lubricate the fan motor annually to ensure the required airflow is provided for proper operation. The fan speed should be checked at the same time. Incorrect pulley settings, loose fan belts, or incorrect motor speeds can all contribute to poor performance. Outdoor units should be protected from high winds. High winds may reduce efficiency by causing defrost problems. However, outdoor units should not be placed in restricted areas that will result in recirculation of air over the coil.

Heat Pump Q&A

Is there a set standard for a heat pump SEER rating in newly constructed homes, and if so what is it?

For all new heat pumps, the minimum SEER is 10.0. Please note that there is difference between HSPF rating and SEER. Check out the energy guide label of the heat pump and check if it meets the Federal requirements.

Is there any easy way to estimate the heating and cooling costs of my heat pump?

There are too many variables to be considered in estimating heating/cooling costs. We recommend that you do a utility audit by contacting your local utility or undertake an analysis or simulation using a program available from any one of the following sites:

http://www.eren.doe.gov/buildings/tools_directory/software/rl5m.htm
http://www.nrel.gov/buildings/energy10

http://www.eren.doe.gov/buildings/tools_directory

I'm searching for information about ground source heat pumps / air conditioning systems. Can you help?

You can check out our contacts and links page on heat pumps for some manufacturers and heat pump installer associations which may give you additional information. Here are a couple of links you could try:

http://www.eren.doe.gov/consumerinfo/refbriefs/bd7.html
http://www.ghpc.org/public/series/serieshp.htm

http://www.epa.gov/appdstar/hvac/geothermal.html

http://www.njhpc.org

Do you have comparison information for different heat pumps?

You may check out the EnergyStar website for comparing product performance. Here are three links with some product comparison information:

http://www.aceee.org/consumerguide/
http://www.epa.gov/appdstar/hvac/geothermal.html

http://www.epa.gov/appdstar/hvac/gas.html

I would like to know more about heat pump suppliers/manufacturers.

You can look at our heat pump contacts and links page for several sources including some regional and international links for heat pump supplier information.

Is it true that heat pumps are more expensive and don't work as well as steam radiators and forced air systems?

There are many factors that determine the effectiveness of a heat pump system. For example, your location, building size, occupancy, insulation levels, utility rate, etc. We recommend that you contact the local utility or Heat pump installer/HVAC contractor to find out about the cost effectiveness.

Is a heat pump with a scroll compressor is more efficient than a heat pump with a reciprocating compressor?

Scrolls are generally more efficient (less moving parts hence less friction losses and no re-expansion of vapors in the cylinders). However, the temperatures reached in the condenser are more a function of system design than anything to do with the type of compressor.

During the cold winter months, my heat pump is getting frost on the outside of the compressor. Is this a problem?

No. Ice build-up is inevitable when the outdoor coil temperature is below freezing. Heat pumps typically have a defrost cycle that melts the ice by running the compressor in reverse for a brief period. It operates either on a timer or based on some other sensor that detects the build-up.

 

Article Tools

BuildersTALK


Ask an Expert
Recent Questions
Click to Pay

Archives


2006-2007
Oct-Dec 2002
Jul-Sep 2002
Jan-Jun 2002
Jul-Dec 2001
Jan-Jun 2001
1999-2000

 

 


ASTM International